Skip to main content

You launched a startup in Dallas with sheer grit, creative vision and long hours. As the venture takes off, you need to add a small team to keep pace with customer demands and growth plans. But before rushing into hiring, employment paperwork and payroll feel daunting for first-time entrepreneurs.

Questions and uncertainty around paying independent contractors vs W-2 employees emerges. How much to withhold for income taxes without underpaying? What about social security, Medicare and unemployment percentages? Are there other state/local agencies needing cuts too?

We get it - payroll feels overwhelming for startup solopreneurs. But in today’s digital age, a plethora of cloud-based payroll solutions help automate and simplify this critical piece of owning a business so you avoid risks. Let’s walk through payroll basics in this beginner’s guide.

Determining Worker Classifications

First things first – you must properly classify workers as either:

W-2 Employees Or 1099 Independent Contractors

The IRS provides clear criteria about what defines these worker classifications centered around your company’s level of control over the worker.

For example 1099 contractors have autonomy in how/where work gets completed. They typically provide their own tools and set schedules. Partnerships with 1099s have defined length/outputs.

Meanwhile W-2 employees work more directly under company direction using company tools/locations/hours. The business controls more elements of the working relationship across a longer horizon.

Pro Tip: Consult an accounting expert serving startups if unsure about worker classification, misclassifying can lead to painful IRS penalties.

Calculating Tax Withholdings

Once workers are properly classified, determine what/how much to withhold from paychecks to remit to federal, state and local tax agencies. Again, requirements differentiate for W-2 employees vs 1099 contractors.

Employers must withhold federal income taxes from employee paychecks based on details like salary amount, pay frequency, and number of allowances the worker claims on Form W-4 which estimates their tax obligation.

Additionally, you must withhold 7.65% of gross pay for Social Security and Medicare taxes. Plus, adhere to rules around providing employee benefits like health insurance, 401k matching and equity compensation.

Alternatively for contractors, simply send a Form 1099 by the end of each tax year declaring what you paid them. Avoid getting into withholdings unless special industry-specific rules apply.

Pro Tip: Plug employee or contractor payment details into online payroll calculators for help determining accurate withholdings amounts. Apps also confirm proper tax rates across local/state/federal agencies.

Choosing DIY Payroll Software

Today’s cloud-based payroll solutions make what was once complex desktop software accessible for lean startups. Options like Gusto, OnPay and QuickBooks Payroll let you pay, file taxes and produce year-end tax documents like W-2s and 1099s in a few clicks for reasonable monthly fees.

Ideally seek platforms providing:

  • Unlimited pay runs

  • Direct deposit

  • Auto tax filings

  • 1099 capabilities

  • Employee self-onboarding

  • mobile apps

  • API connections to accounting software

  • Payroll cards

Pro Tip: Before committing long-term, take advantage of free trials or demos to confirm the payroll provider handles your worker mix needs from offsetting retirement plans to managing interstate employees.

Still, Payroll Mistakes Sink Startups

Yes, technology empowers startups to potentially DIY payroll processes. But it still requires tax know-how most technical founders lack. One mistake filing quarterly taxes or an IRS penalty from misclassifying a worker can sink fragile bootstrappers.

That’s why even heavily automated solutions only complement the expertise of outsourced payroll partners like Quadri CPA PLLC catering to Dallas startups. Entrust payroll to the specialists so you can get back to your startup's true craft - innovating disruptive offerings customers crave.